The Fourth River - Nature and Culture - A Publication by the MFA in Creative Writing at Chatham University
Aobut the Fourth River Current Issue Archives Submit your work Order Meet the Staff Links
The Fourth River
The Fourth River Blacktail
Alan Rossi

Her parents bought things, baby crap, monitors, a changing station and clothes, and though Katie had wanted to leave Iowa before, she didn’t want to leave when her family was helping out so much, so we hung around. Then the next month her period came. Katie’s doctor explained that the new birth control may have given us a strange reading, and then he told us the more likely reason for the positive tests was that she had had a chemical pregnancy, where pregnancy hormones are present, but that’s all. Her period should now have cleaned her out, he explained. That’s when I decided it was time to go. Katie agreed. I had a job waiting in Flathead Valley in Montana that needed a geologist to scout a possible mining operation. I remember being glad for a lot things then. We were away from her family, there was no baby, and I was finally putting my degrees to use.
In mid-summer, we moved into a house situated in a valley off a gravel road called Farm-to-Market Avenue. Our place was small, two bedrooms, and all cold wood floors. We covered the floors with thick rugs that Katie said would make a difference in the winter. We had a small attic that someone had converted into a family room. We used it only for boxes and junk, the baby furniture that her mother had bought, the crib, dresser, and changing station. Pines surrounded the house and it was always dark inside, even with all the blinds up.
We stayed in the first couple months, holding close to each other, but not saying much. It was the first time either of us had lived in another state. Katie grew her brown hair long and her face looked different with so much hair, thinner, older.
I worked out of a cabin with two other guys, Daryl and Tad. They each brought flasks to work and I brought Katie most days to get her out of the house. She hadn’t found a job yet and Daryl and Tad didn’t mind. Katie liked the cabin. It had an old-fashioned black stove that we built a fire in, and she made us tea and cooked us hotdogs in the fire while we played euchre. The cabin had windows on all sides except the back, and my desk, equipped with a laptop, looked out onto a prairie that led to a mountain base. One day I was at my desk, looking at a sample of alluvium sediment and Katie asked what I was doing.
Basically I’m just looking through dirt and sand, I said.
Are you looking for Alkali? she said.
Not even close, I said, and looked up. She had a hotdog on a stick in the fire. It was charred on one side.
You better pay attention to that, I said.
Oh yeah, she said, looking at the hotdog, and then she took the stick, flicked it around, cooling it. The hotdog flipped off and hit me in the chest. I grabbed it and burned my hand.
What the hell? That’s hot.
I didn’t mean to, she said.
Bullshit.
Okay, I’m glad it hit you. Let’s do something. I want to do something. We should get a gun so I can hunt.
We don’t need a gun, I said. I looked at the dirt and sand in the tray on my desk and then I grabbed Katie’s hand, threw the stick and hotdog into the fire, and we went for a walk.
Katie came to work often. The first snow fell early that fall and in the afternoons we walked the base of the Swan Mountains to collecting samples. Katie walked with me and it reminded me of being with her in Iowa, before we had moved so close to her parents, before anything with the pregnancy happened. When we were in college, she had wanted to be a painter. She used to take me to places, rundown antique shops, broken farmhouses, junkyards, and I’d follow her, watch her watching things, doing what she called trying to get an angle on things; she was a dedicated artist then, but not a very good one and she eventually gave it up. She sometimes sketched me, or took my picture. I liked the way she looked at me then, focusing hard to draw a cheekbone, getting a line right on my nose.
When she walked with us, I didn’t show her rocks or mineral formations or anything; I didn’t try to talk to her. I let her come to me, and she did. It was like we were new again, like being away from Iowa in some new place opened things up for us. Sometimes we found things other than rocks. Once, when walking near some trail, we found a cross-country ski.
This is mine, Katie had said. This is so mine. She took the ski and tried to stick her boot into the bindings. She got her foot in there and skied one-legged down small rolls in the fields, falling in the snow.
I began to hunt for other things for her. Another time we found a hatchet in a tree, and Katie walked with the hatchet, hacking off tree limbs in the forest, clearing brush and clearing a way for us. She cut her name deep into the bark of a tree, thick slashes in the wood. She broke through the ice in a pond with the back end of the hatchet. When she got tired of the hatchet, she dropped it.
You’re not going to keep this, I said, picking the hatchet up off the pine needles.
What for? she said, and walked on.
You should keep a collection of the stuff you find, I said. You could decorate the cabin with it.
You keep it then, she said. It’s only fun for a minute. What am I going to do with a hatchet?
I kept the hatchet and put it in the attic.
Another time it was a bucket hanging from a tree, filling up with sap, which Daryl stole to make syrup with. We saw blacktail deer several times, a sturdier, bigger animal than Midwest deer, and Katie tried to take pictures. She took pictures of birds, stray dogs, squirrels. A couple times she tried to photograph fish in a creek. She talked about photographing a bear or deer. When we came across blacktail, Katie’s pictures always came out a blur, the deer sprinting off. Katie would look at her digital camera, show me the blurry photograph, and she’d say, I can’t ever get a good one. And she’d go off on her own, taking pictures of the trees and mountains.
I let Katie be when it seemed like that was what she wanted. Walking with Daryl and Tad, though, I began to enjoy things again, watching the fog lift off the valley to hang around the high peaks. In each direction, there were mountains, and if you looked at them the wrong way, they felt like walls.
One afternoon when Katie didn’t come to work, I hunted for mineral deposits with Daryl and Tad. We found a dead moose instead, the body preserved in the snow, the antlers still intact. The moose lay on a downslope of land, near the forest, and its head pulled backward toward its spine, like it had slipped coming down from the woods and broken its neck.
Let’s say we killed it, Daryl said.
I don’t own a gun, I said.
My wife made me get one when we moved up here, Tad said. It’s a little revolver. We could say I shot it.
I don’t think that would do the trick here, Daryl said, watching the moose. Unless you and the moose were playing Russian roulette or something.
Daryl knelt down next to the moose and searched for wounds, buckshot or anything. His hands crawled through the fur of the thing, messing it. On the back left haunch of the animal, a patch of fur had been scraped away, leaving a large scabbed area of skin. Daryl shook his head, finding nothing.
Let’s cut his head off and mount it, Daryl said, still kneeling, holding the antlers with his right hand like he was posing for a photo.
How are we going to cut the fucking head off a moose? I said.
With a saw, Daryl said.
It’s not like a piece of wood, I said. You can’t just saw it right off. There’s bone to get through.
It’ll be messy, Daryl said. It’ll be messy as hell, but I know a guy in town who’ll fix it all up, stuff it and everything.
I pictured the moose head mounted on the wall of our little cabin, overlooking our desks and laptops, and I liked the thought of it. I didn’t like the idea of cutting off the head, though. I looked at Tad. He held a notepad to his chest, his arms clasped tight around the pad. He wore thick earmuffs that his wife must’ve given him, and a rugged looking flannel coat. His hands and his face were soft, though, almost womanish. He stuck a pen in his mouth and shrugged and said, Okay. Let’s do it. He put the pad in his backpack and we hurried back to my house to get a saw.
Our garage was a two-car, separate from the house, and the door wasn’t electric-powered. We only had one car, a Jeep SUV, and the other side of the space was empty. Daryl and Tad stood behind me, talking about where we could mount the head in the cabin. I pushed the garage door up too fast, and it crashed into place, knocking shovels and saws from the back wall, leaving a clanging echo. It was dark inside the garage, and when my eyes adjusted, I saw Katie huddled in the empty side, a large coke next to her on the ground and a hamburger in her hand. She was trying to get a small goat to come to her. She wore long pajamas and her heavy winter coat and scarf. She was crying, too. Daryl and Tad went quiet behind me. My face flushed.
We’ll be on the front porch, Tad said.
Hi, Katie, Daryl said, and their feet crunched away on the snow and gravel. I stepped into the garage and pulled the string for the light. The little goat looked at me, shivering. It was small, too small, a premature goat.
What’s this doing here? I said.
He was wandering around, Katie said, wiping tears off her cheeks with her left hand, her right hand holding the Whopper. He’s a baby, she said. I think he’s lost.
The goat looked from me to the ground, swinging its head slow. Its legs were thin and knotty, like dead tree branches.
Why were you in the dark?
I don’t know, she said.
Why’d you bring him in here?
Can you stop asking questions? she said.
We didn’t say anything for a minute. Outside the quiet of the garage, the wind hissed and inside a faint little voice, like from a radio, echoed. A puddle of light from her cell phone glowed on the hood of the Jeep, and I picked the phone up, still on, the voice coming out of it. Her mother’s number on the screen.
We should keep him, she said. I think it would be a good idea if we keep him.
Why? I said, looking at the phone.
I mean because we should take care of something and raise it.
I didn’t look at her; I had thought everything with the baby was past. I think you left her on hold, I said, handing Katie the phone.
She grabbed the phone, told her mother that she would call her back. The wind blew and the garage door shook. Katie rubbed her cheeks with the palm of her hands, the hamburger still in her right hand, gripped between thumb and pointer finger.
You’re going to get grease on your face, I said.
She stared at me and threw down the burger. The goat sniffed it. I walked to the back of the garage. In front of the jeep, shovels and hoes and saws were scattered on the cement. I reset them on the wall, for some reason trying to be very quiet. Then I picked a bow-saw and walked by Katie. I turned back before opening the garage and said, I don’t think they like meat. You might try a little grass from the yard. I opened the garage door.
I know they don’t like meat, she said. I wasn’t feeding him the hamburger. I was using the lettuce.
You might try a little grass from the yard, I said.
And all the grass is dead. There’s snow covering everything.
Well, keep trying the lettuce then, I said. Do you want this closed?
She nodded and I pulled down the garage door.
I got the guys from the porch and we drove back to the moose, a little rain sprinkling down, washing away the snow, patches of grass and rock showing on the fields beside the road. On the way, Tad asked if Katie was okay and I didn’t answer him because I didn’t know the answer. Part of me wanted to be back there with her, and the other part wanted to be far away from whatever it was she was feeling. Daryl got to talking on the moose, saying we should cut off the head, and for most of the drive, I thought it was a good idea. Daryl kept going, telling about a deer he killed with his Bronco in Denver, how he got venison for a year, and when he stopped, Tad said that his wife didn’t like it up here at first either.
The people are different, he said.
She likes it fine, I said. It’s just cold.
When we got to the moose, its head heavy against the snow, its one eye glazed white and looking at us, I knew I couldn’t cut the head off. I thought of Katie with the goat; I thought of her dog and cats in Iowa, how they always wanted to be near her, how she had once wanted an animal called a sugar glider. I thought of her standing behind me, watching me, and I didn’t want to see the moose opened up, having to hold the animal’s head steady, the skin coming loose, the rasping sound of cutting through bone, blood leaking everywhere. It looked like it would take a while, too. We decided we would just cut off the antlers, to keep things cleaner. Daryl sawed. He cut them off just above where the antler met the head. I didn’t expect it, but the antlers bled and bled.
In Iowa, I worked in Katie’s mother and father’s butcher shop. The shop was called Cline’s. Her father, Owen Cline, also owned the town paper, but her mother told me they didn’t have a position for me there. So I told Mrs. Cline I would handle the finances of the butcher place, but I wouldn’t work with all the meat. I don’t know why I said this. I didn’t mind cutting meat. It may have had something to do with having a master’s degree; a person with a master’s degree doesn’t cut meat all day. When I told her I would be glad to handle the finances and the marketing of the place, she started laughing.
The finances? she said. The marketing? Oh, we gotta take you to Mr. Klegg.
Two days later we drove in Owen’s pickup down to a farm on the edge of town, in the middle of Iowa flatland. I wondered what kind of farm work Mrs. Cline was going to have me do, and thought it stupid of her and immature not to tell me the reason for taking me to a farm. Mrs. Cline has a flat, oval face, and she kept her lips pursed as we drove, as though she was holding a surprise for me in. I turned the radio on and she turned it down a little.
Then she said, We get the cows from another place now, already slaughtered, but I wanted you to see how we used to do it. You’ve been in school most of your life, so you’ve probably never had to do work like this. Has Katie ever told you about the farm work she did for Mr. Klegg?
I told her no.
This is part of it, she said.
It was nearing sundown when we got to the place, the sky white and grey, the farmhouse and barn the only thing for miles. Rows of soybeans stretched away on the other side of the road and it looked as though you could walk right off the earth. A dead tree, stark as bone, stood in the middle of the field. I waited in the driveway of the farmhouse while Mrs. Cline got Mr. Klegg from around back.
Klegg was a very old, very short man who wore glasses, and when he shook my hand, he looked past me, like he was trying to see something behind me. They took me to the barn that looked like hell on the outside, the paint stripped from the wood, but was clean inside, hard-packed dirt floors and cleaned out pens, even the stench of livestock wasn’t terrible. At the back of the barn, Klegg brought out a cow, its head with rope around it, almost like a dog’s muzzle. We walked out the back of the barn, passing the other animals, and the smell of shit and hay grew fainter. Flies buzzed around the cow’s ass. I walked at Klegg’s side and Katie’s mother walked behind us. We stopped at the end of the fence surrounding the barn where Klegg had laid out three pails of cold water, a length of chain, a hoist, a .30-06 rifle, and a large knife. He told me and Mrs. Cline to grab everything except the rifle, which he picked up and carried. I grabbed the water pails, which I later learned were to hold the heart, liver, and kidney. I stuck the knife in my back pocket, the handle up underneath my shirt. Mrs. Cline grabbed the hoist and chain. We walked on, Klegg leading, water from the pails spilling onto my jeans. We walked far, down into a pasture behind the barn, toward a large tree with a long thick limb extending out parallel with the ground. My heart raced. The cow seemed to sense something, something about the strangeness of being away from the other animals, surrounded by the three of us. We stopped when we got to the tree; there were striations on the thick limb, bark rubbed away from where other cows had hung up to drain.
This’ll be your first one, Mrs. Cline said, coming around the animal to us. We’ll teach you how to butcher it start to finish.
I said that they didn’t have to do this for me.
This isn’t for you, Mrs. Cline said. We do a cow every year for Mr. Klegg. She looked at Klegg.
Every year, he said, checking something on the gun. Klegg looked at us. Step back, you two, he said. Then he looked at me. If you need to walk away, just walk away.
 Without thinking, I asked if the cow would feel anything and then felt foolish for asking. Klegg stopped, lowered the rifle, and took my question in a serious manner, rubbing his forehead with the palm of his right hand.
Not if you do it right, he said. You just watch me. We’ll make sure we get it the first time.
After the goat came, Katie changed. She kept him in the garage, chained up. He pissed and shit in the garage and I had to clean it. I found her out there feeding him, talking to him, asking if he wanted to go on a walk. And she took him on walks, at first just around our yard, then up and down our street in the snow. When she came inside the house, she smelled like goat and hay. She wore worn jeans and turtlenecks and was quiet even when she spoke. She was distant, like there really had been a baby and it was miscarried or lost in some other way. I stopped her one day on her way to the goat.
Is he a permanent thing, I said. Don’t you think we need to a find a place for him.
He’s my job now, Katie said. He’s what I do. You know, I thought about taking care of some other strays.
You can’t do that, I said.
You get to go to work everyday so I get to take care of him.
You can come to work with me still, I said. You can get a job.
I don’t want a job, she said. I want to do this.
In November, Daryl, Tad and Katie and I hiked onto a man named Ronnie Telford’s ranchland without knowing it. We didn’t know Telford then, but we would. We were walking to a part of Blacktail Mountain shorn off by a glacier, granite rock exposed. We hiked through an area of woods and then came across a stretch of field, Telford’s fence down. Farmland cut into the middle of the forest, bisecting it for about a hundred yards. We walked on, and I was surprised at how quickly the land opened up. Behind us, Blacktail Mountain stood ringed in clouds. In the distance, to our right in the valley, sat a one-story house, looking part of the land, and a road, and then a white Ford truck bouncing toward us. We all four stopped and watched it coming. The truck ducked down and up from the long hilly road leading up to the house. It moved fast, faster than I first thought. The diesel growled in the distance and smoke billowed out of the back of the truck, the engine getting louder, the truck going faster, dirt and rocks spewing from under the tires. Tad put his hands up. Katie did the same.
He’s not going to shoot us, I said.
Then why’s he driving so fast? Tad said.
The truck suddenly cut off the road, an explosion of dust behind it, and headed right at us. I got scared and raise my hands. Daryl’s went up, too. The truck slowed down when all our hands went up, and Katie laughed, Tad let out a breath, and we all lowered our hands. Then the truck sped up again, kicking rocks from beneath the tires, spinning out in the dirt, and Tad said, Run. And I turned to go.
He’s messing with us, Daryl said, grabbing my coat. It’s cool.
The truck fishtailed to a stop. A skinny man with a beard and a flannel shirt rolled down his window. He asked us our business on his property. Daryl and I stepped forward, and I showed him my papers and my NMGA card and explained about looking for outcropping mineral deposits or any deposits under heavy sediment or regolith. He squinted his eyes at me and looked confused. Behind him in the truck hung an empty gun rack.
A company hired us to find a place to mine, I said.
Any luck? he said.
Not a thing, Tad said. Sorry we’re on your property.
The man squinted at Tad, then looked back to me. He handed me my papers from the cab of his truck, nodded, and said, Just ask if you’re going to pass through my land. He was about to drive off when Katie spoke up.
What kind of farm do you have? she said.
It’s a ranch, he said. We’ve got horses mainly.
I used to ride horses, she said. My dad used to take me out.
We do rides here, the ranch man said. It’s a little way to make money. I could set you up if you all wanted.
Do you have any goats? Katie said.
We’ve got a few goats, he said. A lot of folks around here have goats. My brother lives in Copper Falls and he’s got goats in a residential area, just in his backyard.
We have one, she said.
We don’t have one, I cut in. We’re looking to give one away. It’s a stray.
A stray goat? Daryl said.
Katie looked at me. I found one is what I meant to say, she said, looking back at the ranch man. Just a baby one. I can’t get him to eat.
I’d be happy to take a look at him, the ranch man said. He didn’t say anything for a minute, then he swung his arm, motioning to Katie. Let’s go take a look at him, he said.
Katie climbed in the cab of the truck. They shook hands and I heard the man say, Ronnie Telford. Katie smiled at him and said her name. She leaned across the seat, near to the ranch man, shoulder to shoulder, and said to me, I’ll meet you at home. They drove off, back toward the ranch house.
She seems happy today, Tad said.
Did she not before? I said.
Some weekends we watched her parents’ house. They had a condo on Lake Michigan and took a boat up there once a month. We looked after the dog and two cats and got to stay in the two-story house. It was an antique thing. Around every corner sat a wood end table with a lamp and doily and a photo on it. Faded black and white photographs of people and old houses hung on the walls in the family room. An old brick fireplace, blackened and cracking, sunk to one side in the family room. When we thought Katie was pregnant, her parents still took the trip to Lake Michigan, and stayed longer than usual. I think it was her father’s idea. They stayed away for about a week, to give us time to talk things through. We didn’t talk, though. We pretended the problem wasn’t there. Or we pretended it wasn’t a problem.
Katie went on walks a lot or went to the Y to swim. She said this was because she needed to be out of her parents’ house. She’d come back, smelling of chlorine each day, her hair still wet. She didn’t take showers and said the pool got her clean. It was clear to me that not only did she want to be out of the house, she didn’t want to be around me. And I suspected things then. I suspected the chlorine-smell maybe hid some other smell. I thought she might be seeing some other swimmer, doing laps with him, or synchronized swimming, or letting one of the lifeguards watch her body.
After she got home one afternoon and was sitting on an upstairs bed, dripping into the comforter, I asked if she’d mind if I swam with her.
Actually, I would mind, she said, ruffling her still wet hair. Nobody’s ever there when I go in the morning. It’s my own thing. You go under water, you stay under, and it’s like your own little world down there, and you can feel that world, feel it against your limbs.
Limbs, I thought when she was talking. What a word.
It’s quiet and different and it’s yours, she said. Plus, I’ve never known you to be too into exercise.
So there’s not some good looking lifeguard, I said.
You’re a perverted idiot, she said.
How’s that perverted? I said. Your use of the word limbs is perverted.
Is it going to be like this? she said, standing up, the butt of her bathing suit sagging. Is it going to be like this when I have the baby?
I told her it probably was and she went off to take a walk.
I remember, when Katie was gone somewhere during the day, how I walked around the house, looking at the empty rooms. There were rooms no one used anymore. A living room with neat beige furniture, an oriental rug, and a coffee table. The sofa faced two windows with a view of the flat fields behind the house, and when the sun set, the room turned yellow. Katie told me about playing with her dog in there, but I couldn’t picture it. Three bedrooms upstairs with neatly made beds and large oak dressers. Leaves of a nearby tree made shadows in the room farthest down the hall, and I sat in there a lot, listening to the tree rustle in the breeze. In that room, I found two rusted pistols in a drawer, a broken light gauge device, a box of bullets, an inhaler, fountain pens, pictures of when Katie was little, eyes wide and smiling, and two degrees that Katie’s father had taken, one in journalism, the other in business. The other drawers were full of stuff, too. The bedrooms had turned into junk rooms, places for storage, nothing more.
Ronnie Telford had run a ranch for nearly twenty-five years. He was our parents’ age and had lived in Montana all his life. His second wife, Tammy, helped him run the ranch; his first died in a skiing accident, though Telford told us little of that. He had two children with his first wife, both girls, and they were away at college.
Once a week or so, Telford brought a small bale of hay for the goat. He gave it shots, and a de-wormer, but wouldn’t take the thing. He and Katie talked in the garage, standing around with the goat. Sometimes I went in, but I didn’t say much, I just listened to the two of them. Katie stopped coming to work with me.
I got home from the cabin each day to find Katie and Ronnie and Tammy outside building a small fence on the back of the garage. At the back of the fence, they put up a little shelter, a little hut, and filled it with hay. A week or so into the work, they got the whole thing pretty much finished just as I got home. I walked up to the fence, rested on it, and was about to say that it looked good, when Telford said, Hey, would you mind getting some bedding down here? She wants bedding in here.
I wanted to tell him to go get the bedding himself, but I said yes, and went inside to the loft filled with boxes. The antlers we had cut from the dead moose were in a corner of the room on the floor. Next to the antlers was the hatchet Katie had found. I was supposed to mount both the antlers and the hatchet, bring them to the geology cabin, but I hadn’t done it yet. I reminded myself to do this and then searched for old bedding. In the first box, I found a good blender and set it out, along with three pairs of broken earphones, and sketches Katie made. The first two were of me, looking away from her. In one, I sat on some stairs, talking on the phone, my eyes looking at the ground. In another, I stood, looked out a window. I could tell the window was from our old apartment. I didn’t remember doing either of these things, but it didn’t matter. That Katie had drawn them mattered; that I had somehow captured her attention, her love, in those moments—I wanted that back. I flipped through the drawings. Other sketches: her mother walking the dog; her father in their backyard; a whole assortment of Iowa landscapes; a pond; a field with snow; ducks in the sky; a woman and a boy on a road in the small town.
What’re you doing? Katie shouted from downstairs.
I put the sketches away. I found a blender, I said.
Bring the bedding, she said, coming up the stairs. Isn’t this great? It’s pretty much finished; we could probably have a couple more goats. Or a dog or whatever. She came up further into the loft and gave me a kiss on the cheek.
We don’t need any more goats, I said. We don’t need anymore anything.
You suck sometimes, she said, and grabbed the bedding from me.
After giving the bedding to her, I walked down our driveway to get the mail. When I came back up, Ronnie was loading tools and extra fence slats and wood into his truck. His wife said goodbye to me and got into the cab of the truck. I walked up to the truck, put my hands on the bed. I asked him why he didn’t take the goat.
Your wife wants it, he told me. And I don’t need anymore goats. I’m scaling back. I’m nearing retirement, he said, showing his teeth, one front tooth with a little black hole in the top of it. Hey, he said. Tell Katie we’ll be ready for dinner around seven. Just stop by any time before then.
I told him okay and went inside to ask Katie about dinner.
Sometime after Thanksgiving, a package arrived for Katie. She was gone, at the Telford’s, and I opened it. The box contained a videotape and a small note, written on a piece of scrap paper, that read, Katie, We thought you’d like this. Hope it’s not too cold up there. Go skiing, go to the Y, get some exercise, you’ll feel better. We’ll visit soon; we want to do a cross country trip. And let us know how the goat is? Love, M and D.

It was her mother’s handwriting. When her mother called and I answered the phone, she didn’t acknowledge me, didn’t ask me how I was, what I had been up to, or even what we had been up to. The note was addressed only to Katie and that annoyed me, made me want to throw it out, along with the tape. I didn’t, though. I cooled down.
I decided to wait for Katie to watch the tape, so I put on coffee, then decided I wouldn’t wait and sat in the family room, on one of our heavy rugs, and put in the tape. It began with a view of her house in Iowa, and I couldn’t believe someone would send such a thing. We had just moved, after all. After watching a minute, though, the tape felt gentle to me, desperate even. The camera zoomed close to a fuzzy window, then zoomed out again, bringing almost the entire house in clear, the white siding dirty in spots, the blue shutters around the windows faded grey. A wind was going and the tall tree on the right side of the house rustled. The tree trunk bent in the middle, away from the house, as if trying to get out of the shade, and I had never noticed this before. The camera danced from the tree to the house. Wind made a hollow gushing sound in the camera, but other than that, there was no voice, no commentary. I wondered about that for a second, but then knew there didn’t need to be a voice. Katie already knew all the details. The camera readjusted, followed the path of the front walk up to the front door, then panned up to the roof. Slow. The hand of the camera tried to remain steady but jerked up to the top windows, but still, the camera moved around the house like a blind man’s hands would, feeling it out, loving it. A quick cut to a shot of the empty road leading to the house, a soybean field to the left, a white and blue sky, clouds motionless, and again, no other sound but the wind. I got a sense of the quietness of things. Then the dog jumped into the shot and Mrs. Cline’s voice said to sit, sit. The dog whined and barked, its nose in the camera. The next shot began in the upstairs bedroom, the one I liked to sit in, and the camera zoomed in close to the window. I could see the shadows of leaves in the window. Inside the house, it was even quieter, and as the camera panned around the room, I could hear Mrs. Cline’s feet shuffling and her breathing. The camera stayed in the room, zooming in on the bedspread, along the corner of the blue wall, to the oak dresser, then panned out, finding the whole room. In a corner of the room, above the bed on the dull white ceiling was a water stain. The tape went on like this, recording each room, ending with a shot of the backyard. Katie fell asleep to it that night, and each night afterward for a week or so.
Six bears? Katie said.
Six, Ronnie said, pouring himself another cup of some spiked cider. Two with a bow, he said. But I used all that goddamn meat. And I’ve used the hides. This one here, the big guy, I kept. The other ones, I gave away. That animal gave its life.
We sat in the Telford’s house around a coffee table, behind Katie a fire in the fire place. Out one of the windows, Blacktail Mountain was visible in the darkening sky. When I looked out the window the first time, I thought it was night, but I was really looking at the dark of the mountain, and when I went close up to the window, a grey afternoon sky outlined Blacktail. It was a strange feeling, that mountain looming so close to the house. On the walls of the Telford’s place were all the typical things. A couple deerheads, antlers, and we sat on a bearskin rug, one of Ronnie’s, the big guy he kept calling it. A wood gun case with a glass door sat in the corner of the room, in place of a china closet. The house made our geology cabin, with the little stove and the laptops on plastic desks, look ridiculous.
He’s never even picked up a gun, Katie said, looking at me. He wouldn’t cut meat at my parents’ butcher shop.
Ronnie smiled, his teeth showing, that little black hole at the top of his front tooth. He and Katie were doing all the talking. Tammy got up either to get more cider or to bring out more cheese and crackers. The cheese, some block of white stuff, was very good.
I prefer not dealing with dead animals all day, I said.
You’re not a vegetarian, Ronnie said. We’ve got some good elk I wanted you to taste.
I shook my head. No, I said. I like meat.
Ronnie laughed hard. Well, I like meat, too, he said, and continued laughing. I like meat, he said. That’s funny. He slapped me on the back and got serious looking. It’s the blood, he said. I know. It’s got a smell to it, even all cleaned up. I don’t enjoy that part of it.
I felt like saying I had a degree in geology, two really, but I didn’t. I didn’t like being in the Telford’s house. It was a forty-five minute drive from our house and meeting at their place was becoming a regular thing. I’d already missed a couple euchre nights with Daryl and Tad.
The first thing I killed was a squirrel, Ronnie said. I was maybe ten or twelve or so. I killed it with just a twenty-two, picked it out of a tree. I was a good shot even then. Well, I was going to leave that little piece of shit. I was ten or whatever. No respect for this animal. No idea I’d just took its life.
My dad had me kill a deer with him when I was about ten, Katie said, sounding like a little girl. We butchered it together. He taught me how to hide the thing, drain it, do it all.
Ronnie leaned on the coffee table with both elbows. That’s the way to do it, he said. I can tell something about your old man right there. My own dad wasn’t quite like that. He wasn’t as hands on and there as yours, he said.
The women were listening hard. Ronnie’s face flickered in the firelight.
After I shot that squirrel, well I’m off to shoot something else, he said. But my father finds that squirrel, and he can see the gunshot in it. He finds me around the house, aiming at god knows what. I remember that. He found me lining up some other animal. To this day, I don’t remember what, but there I am, lining up this other animal after I killed this little squirrel. And he yanks the gun out of my hands, empties the bullets, and tells me I can’t shoot another goddamn thing until I finish that squirrel. So I go to throw the thing away, thinking I’ll toss the fucker in the trash. No. No deal. He makes me skin the thing, gut it, build a fire, cook the thing, and eat it. I didn’t shoot another thing for a year.
Katie kept her eyes on Ronnie, waiting. Ronnie grabbed my right shoulder hard, smiling across the table into the fire, his eyes set in shadow.
Another tape from Iowa arrived. Katie watched it then put it upstairs in the junk room with the first tape, the deer antlers, the hatchet, the baby furniture. She went to Telford’s a couple times a week or more and we scheduled New Year’s with them, after they got back from a trip to visit Ronnie’s daughters. I found myself alone in the house after work most days. I often went upstairs and got the tapes. I’d sit with the lights off, watching our old campus pass by on video, trying to see us into the little shops, walking along the roads, before we had any worries, when it was just the two of us, when we lived slow. The tape cut from our campus to the little town, into the Cline’s butcher shop where a man I’ve never seen before waved at the camera, and then the camera dove back out onto the street, and I tried to put us back there, together, when we liked to be together so much, but in my head all I could see was Katie. The memory of her walking on the Iowa street; the moon in the sky lighted her face grey. I wanted to be back there, in Iowa. I remembered walking back from the butcher shop, how she came to meet me and walked me home. She stopped to look in a window at clothes. There were two of her, one on the sidewalk, one in the window.
Let’s play euchre tonight with Tad and Daryl, I said. We haven’t seen them much lately.
You see them everyday, Katie said.
This is true, I said. But that’s in a work environment.
A work environment? she said. All you guys do is jerk off all day.
I think you’re confused, I said. That’s what you do all day.
She took a spoonful of yogurt. Have you tried the key lime pie kind? she said. It’s delicious.
Then she flung a spoonful of yogurt at me. It hit my shirt. She laughed. I’m sorry, she said. I am. She wiped the yogurt off my shirt and said, I’m going to the Telford’s tonight, she said. You can come if you want. You know, I want you to come.
I washed my hands in the sink and she put a hand on the back of my neck. Why? I said.
Because I want to be with you, she said.
At the Telford’s, I said.
I already told them I’d be there.
Why do you like it there? I said. It’s cheesy and silly and all Ronnie does is tell old war stories.
Jesus, she said. It’s better than here. It makes me feel like I’m at home.
How’s that possible? I said. There are dead animals staring at you from every angle of the place.
It’s possible. And those animals were killed for food, she said. You better get used to it, too. He asked me to help out on the ranch and I think I’m going to do it.
Do whatever you want, I said, and walked outside to get away from her.
Neither of us went anywhere that night, and I slept upstairs in the loft, surrounded by boxes.
Sometime before Christmas, I heard Katie get up early. We’d been sleeping in separate rooms. I had taken the loft upstairs, the converted living room. We didn’t have a sofa up there, but I put all the boxes into a crawl space and made a bed on the ground with blankets, the crib and baby furniture in the corner of the room.
I woke up to the sound of the front door opening and closing, and I went to the small triangular window. I saw our Jeep SUV in the driveway, and Katie and Ronnie were piling suitcases into the back of it and into the backseats. It was early, snow had recovered the other snow, making everything white again. A grey light made shadows down in the pines. Everything was quiet. My little room was quiet, and I could just hear the noises Katie and Ronnie made putting the suitcases in the car; their feet had already cleared a path in the snow from the front door to the back of the Jeep, and I listened to the gravel sound. They said little. I put my ear up to the window and felt the cold. They made trip after trip, first the suitcases, then boxes of things, stereo stuff, movies, and I listened to all the junk quietly rattling when they brought it out. I closed my eyes and listened to it. Then I opened my eyes and watched. Katie must have not been able to see in my window. Sometimes she looked up to the loft to see if my light had come on. She’d stop what she was doing and stand, looking up to my window. It was strange to see her face looking that way, watching for me. After some time, I went downstairs, went out the back door and stood by the car. She came from the front door and saw me right away.
I’m not moving out, she said.
I didn’t say you were, I said.
I’m just taking some of our stuff to the Telfords’. They want me to watch their place while they’re on vacation. I’m taking care of the goats and horses and everything. It’s just for a little while, she said.
You’re taking a lot of stuff for a little while, I said. Are you sure you need it all?
Probably not, but I just want to be sure. It’s my stuff anyway.
So let’s be sure then, I said. I went inside and Ronnie was huddled over some drawer in the kitchen. He looked at me. I started in the family room. I grabbed all the copies of National Geographic that were hers and put them in a box. I pulled some decorative tea set down from the bookshelf, a tea set I’d bought, and put that in. I filled the box up with CDs, mine, hers, it didn’t matter. I went upstairs and grabbed the hatchet she’d found, the moose antlers and put those in the box. Then I brought the box out to the car. My hands were freezing, holding the thing, and I dropped it in the back of the Jeep. Clouds broke in the sky and I saw a little blue behind the grey covering.
That’s not all mine, she said. I don’t want any antlers.
I got them for you, I said.
You didn’t get them for me.
Ronnie clapped his hands together and said, Anything else?
Yeah, I said. There’s a lot more. Fuck. There’s fucking plenty more.
Let’s go, Ronnie, Katie said. This is all I need.
Ronnie looked at me. Then he went and got in his truck. Katie got the box I had just put in the Jeep and set it in the snow.
Take this back in, she said.
I didn’t pay her any attention and went back inside the house. I could see my breath in the air. There’s a lot more of your shit, I yelled out to Katie. I stood in the family room, no longer angry, just tired and embarrassed. I heard the Jeep start up and then Ronnie’s diesel truck. I waited until I heard the truck going and then went outside again. Ronnie’s truck was already down the driveway, signaling to turn onto the road. I was glad he was gone. The tires of the Jeep crunched snow and Katie tapped the brakes, rolled down her window.
It’s only for a few weeks, she said. I’ll invite you for dinner some nights. Ronnie told me I can cook whatever deer meat I want.
I didn’t say anything for a minute. Exhaust from the Jeep curled around my legs.
Take care of the goat, she said, and started to roll up her window.
I’ll surprise you, I said fast, putting my hand on the window.
She didn’t say anything to this. Her window buzzed and rolled down again and I took my hand away.
I’ll get Daryl to drive me and I’ll just surprise you, I said.
She smiled at me and then rolled up her window, waved, and drove off.
I picked up the box off the ground and brought it inside. I sat on the rug in front of the television. Snow clung to the bottom of the box and melted into the carpet. I thought about Katie living in the Telfords’ house, cooking herself dinner, feeding the horses on the ranch, taking care of the few chickens they had. I thought about her alone, moving through their rooms, maybe looking in their drawers, trying on some of Tammy’s clothes, wearing overalls to do ranch work, stepping into Ronnie’s boots for a quick walk to get the mail. I went upstairs and got the videos her mother had sent. I decided that I might drive them over and bring the goat, too; I’d help out with the ranch and feed the animals and we’d ride horses and I’d get my work done that way. But it would be her way, too. Then I realized I didn’t have a car. I sat on the floor again, the videos in my lap, and pictured the drive over with Daryl, how I’d wait to do it for a few days, maybe a week, but then go around dusk. I would wander the property like a stranger, pretending to be lost and in need of shelter, would creep close to the house and peek in the windows, and see her through a window as though I’d never seen her before; I’d watch her doing whatever she might be doing, watching TV, calling her parents, sleeping, and then I’d just walk right in.
The Fourth River